I give it a 4 star only because I had to re-glue the hatch hinge. - Whatever glue the manufacturer used failed after one time out. - No big deal! (Marine grade JW Weld is great!!) - Other than that, and after years of paddling cheap, sit inside, 8 footers, I love the Manta Ray 12 XT - It's the SUV of kayaks!! - Most of my paddling is saltwater (Gulf side of Florida) - Water can get choppy but I can paddle this kayak with confidence. - Very stable, with great storage capacity!! - I'm not an avid kayak fisherman (yet) - But I can pack a load on this kayak and explore the local spoil islands for a day (or more) and carry everything I need. - They were marked up at 800.00 at our local outfitter (I got two for 700 ea). - We live 5 minutes from the Gulf so it was a great investment.