I have one without the top and have had it for 6 years. Ive not used it as much as i'd like too, but it paddles easily, moves fast, straight, and is aluminum tough. As stable as any kayak and holds more pounds than most (Im over 200 lbs). I saw the seat mentioned. I replaced the seat with one that is just the same except with padding. Not hard to do if you are mechanically inclined but not super easy either. Wont matter for most people but I like some padding. I like the kayak and its a great deal for the price. Would buy again.