I initially had no problems with the seat popping, however, now after several years use, in spite of tightening the strap as much as strength allows, it continues to pop out almost every trip now, most recently and frighteningly in some (up to that point) fun swifts in a lock outflow, but also regularly with calm water paddling. One clip of the plastic buckle has detached over the length of a trip, however most commonly the rear seat tube simply jumps out of its bracket. Any safe suggestions short of a ratchet or cam buckle strap and the risk of damaging the mounting brackets or hull would be greatly appreciated. I have checked the Old Town website and was unable to find a fix.
It is adequate for lake canoeing, although there is a learning curve to keep it tracking straight and dry in adverse conditions. Speed is fine with the Old Town kayak paddle, less effective with a canoe paddle and impossible (for me) with a Greenland paddle. The seat is comfortable over the short term (several hours) but numbness sets in thereafter. I use a marine seat cushion to raise the paddling height, well worth the loss of stability to be higher for paddling as well as easier entry and exit.
It is an ok product, however I would suggest a long test paddle and confirming your comfort level carrying overhead and on your shoulder before purchasing.
Boat looks excellent for my intended use, seat is great, colour coordinated paddles a nice feature, so buy, but before you buy (in case mine's not a one off issue), look stem to stern over dealer's inventory to get undamaged hull and to be reassured that the seat slides freely through the full range of the rails.
For the old and frail such as I, note that the weight is 53 pounds as now spec'd (different with and without the removable seat, of course).